Prosecutors 'Doing Justice' Through Osmosis - Reminders to Encourage a Culture of Cooperation
Issue Date
2008Author
Wilson, Melanie D.
Publisher
Case Western Reserve University School of Law
Type
Article
Version
http://ssrn.com/abstract=1004770
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
Scholars have often criticized the government for relying on "cooperating" defendant/witnesses in obtaining convictions of other persons. Such scholars contend that cooperating witnesses are powerfully motivated to parrot information a prosecutor wants to hear and that as naturally biased advocates, prosecutors overlook and ignore signs that cooperating defendants are lying.
This article asserts that defendants who "cooperate" with the government by substantially assisting in the prosecution of other crimes and criminals in exchange for a hope of receiving a more lenient sentence are invaluable crime prevention tools and should be encouraged. Nevertheless, the article recognizes the inconsistent manner in which prosecutors assess such witnesses, primarily because of the unfettered discretion prosecutors wield over cooperators. The law imposes no duty on prosecutors to deal critically or carefully with cooperating defendants. If prosecutors bear such a duty, and the article contends that they do, the obligation originates with a prosecutor's ethical duty "to do justice."
The article explores a void in the legal and ethics literature regarding the federal prosecutor's ethical obligations around cooperating defendants. It discusses the nebulous nature of the duty to "do justice" in the context of evaluating, selecting or rejecting cooperation and ultimately concludes that the Department of Justice can further the prosecutor's ethical responsibility of dealing thoughtfully and thoroughly with cooperators by fostering an office culture in which critical and thoughtful assessment of such witnesses is rewarded.
Description
Full-text available at SSRN. See link in this record.
Collections
Citation
Melanie D. Wilson, Prosecutors 'Doing Justice' Through Osmosis - Reminders to Encourage a Culture of Cooperation, 45 AM. CRIM. L. REV. 67 (2008).
Items in KU ScholarWorks are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.
We want to hear from you! Please share your stories about how Open Access to this item benefits YOU.