ATTENTION: The software behind KU ScholarWorks is being upgraded to a new version. Starting July 15th, users will not be able to log in to the system, add items, nor make any changes until the new version is in place at the end of July. Searching for articles and opening files will continue to work while the system is being updated. If you have any questions, please contact Marianne Reed at .

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.authorGomulkiewicz, Richard
dc.contributor.authorSlade, Norman A.
dc.identifier.citationGomulkiewicz, R., and N. A. Slade. 1997. Legal standards and the significance of DNA evidence. Human Biology 69:675-688.
dc.descriptionThis is the publisher's version. It is also available electronically from:
dc.description.abstractMost human biologists are aware of controversies regarding the use of DNA profiles in the courtroom. Much attention has been given to estimating the probability of obtaining matches between DNA samples from an innocent suspect and those from a crime scene, but considerably less attention has been given to the critical issue of determining the probability of guilt given a match. Using Bayes' rule and simple algebra, we develop a measure of the strength of DNA evidence that indicates the amount of incriminating evidence needed in combination with DNA match evidence to meet a given conviction standard. Based on current standards and practices, we use this measure to demonstrate that (1) the amount of non-DNA evidence needed to convict, given a DNA match, generally is quite small, even if errors can occur in the processing of DNA evidence: (2) DNA match evidence alone is insufficient to convict, even for the lowest recognized conviction standards; (3) failure to match DNA evidence samples should be exculpatory unless laboratory proficiency is poor; and (4) if errors in handling evidentiary samples occur (even rarely) that tend to produce a false DNA match, then the legal significance of DNA evidence is remarkably insensitive to estimates of chance match probability.
dc.publisherWayne State University Press
dc.subjectBAYES' RULE
dc.subjectDNA PROFILE
dc.titleLegal Standards and Significance of DNA Evidence
kusw.kuauthorGomulkiewicz, Richard
kusw.kuauthorSlade, Norman A.
kusw.kudepartmentSystematics and Ecology
kusw.kudepartmentSystematics and Ecology and Natural History
kusw.oaversionScholarly/refereed, publisher version
kusw.oapolicyThis item meets KU Open Access policy criteria.

Files in this item


This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record