Loading...
Recommended by Librarians: A Computational Citation Analysis Methodology for Identifying and Examining Books Promoted in LibGuides
Orth-Alfie, Carmen Wolfe, Erin
Orth-Alfie, Carmen
Wolfe, Erin
Citations
Altmetric:
Abstract
To study library guides, as published on Springshare’s LibGuides platform, new approaches are needed to expand the scope of the research, ensure comprehensiveness of data collection, and reduce bias for content analysis. Computational methods can be utilized to conduct a nuanced and thorough evaluation that critically assesses the resources promoted in library guides. Web-based library guides are curated by librarians to provide easy access to high-quality information and resources in a variety of formats to support the research needs of their users. Recent scholarship considers library guides as valuable resources and as de facto publications, highlighting the need for critical study. In this article, the authors present a novel model for comprehensively gathering data about a specific genre of books from individual LibGuide pages and applying computational methods to explore the resultant data. Beginning with a pre-selected list of 159 books, we programmatically queried the titles using the LibGuides Community search engine. After cleaning and filtering the resultant data, we compiled a list of 20,484 book references (of which 6,212 are unique) on 1,529 LibGuide pages. By testing against inclusion and exclusion criteria to ensure relevancy, we identified a total of 281 titles relevant to our topic. To gain insights for future study, citation analysis metrics are presented to reveal patterns of frequency, co-occurrence, and bibliographic coupling of books promoted in LibGuides. This proof-of-concept could be adopted for a variety of applications, including assessment of collections, public services, critical librarianship, and other complex questions to enable a richer and more thorough understanding of the information landscape of LibGuides.
Description
The dataset and the series of Jupyter notebooks created for the collection and analysis of the data used in this article can be found at https://doi.org/10.17161/1808.34184.
Date
2024-03-18
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
American Library Association
Collections
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Keywords
LibGuides, Library guides, Content analysis, Citation analysis, Co-citation, Print and electronic books, Computational methods, Research methodology, Python
Citation
Orth-Alfie, C., & Wolfe, E. (2024). Recommended by Librarians: A Computational Citation Analysis Methodology for Identifying and Examining Books Promoted in LibGuides. Information Technology and Libraries, 43(1). https://doi.org/10.5860/ital.v43i1.16687