Loading...
Improving Infrastructure Sustainability I: Extending Useable Lives of Steel Bridges by Halting Distortion-Induced Fatigue Crack Propagation Using Pretensioned Bolts and Plate Washers
Liu, Hao Bennett, Caroline Matamoros, Adolfo Li, Jian Barrett-Gonzalez, Ron Rolfe, Stan
Liu, Hao
Bennett, Caroline
Matamoros, Adolfo
Li, Jian
Barrett-Gonzalez, Ron
Rolfe, Stan
Citations
Altmetric:
Abstract
Drilling crack-arrest holes to halt fatigue crack propagation is a simple technique that is commonly used by bridge owners controlling and/or repairing fatigue cracking in steel bridges. Well-established relationships exist for sizing the diameter of the crack-arrest holes for in-plane fatigue loading; however, the effectiveness of crack-arrest holes under out-of-plane (distortion-induced) fatigue is not well-understood.
Distortion-induced fatigue cracking is much more common in steel bridge infrastructure than in-plane fatigue cracking, and bridge owners often utilize drilled crack-arrest holes in these cases as a “first response” against fatigue cracks discovered during inspections. The purpose of the crack-arrest hole is to smooth out the sharp crack tip, reducing the stress concentration and halting/delaying crack propagation. Common knowledge has been that large diameter crack- arrest holes are more effective at halting crack propagation under distortion-induced fatigue than small diameter crack arrest holes. However, drilling large diameter crack-arrest holes can have strength implications for a structure, and may not be desirable. Additionally, there is little evidence in the literature that large diameter crack-arrest holes perform better than small diameter crack-arrest holes under distortion-induced fatigue.
A study examining the effectiveness of crack-arrest holes of varying diameters under
distortion-induced fatigue loading was performed. The investigation was comprised of both
experimental and analytical components. The experimental study was performed on segments of
plate girder loaded under distortion-induced fatigue. Crack-arrest holes of various diameters
were drilled at the tips of the cracks of different lengths, and their effectiveness were
evaluated. A suite of three-dimensional, solid-element finite element analyses was also used to
parametrically vary crack-arrest hole diameter, placement, and crack length. The study also included an analytical examination of using pretensioned bolts and plate washers in a crack-arrest hole. Limited effectiveness was noted for this technique, so the majority of the research focused on appropriate crack-arrest hole sizing and placement.
The findings from the experimental and analytical components of this study were compared against common industry practices. The results show that crack-arrest hole placement, rather than hole diameter, has a much greater effect on the effectiveness of the crack arrest hole in bridge girders susceptible to distortion-induced fatigue.
Description
Date
2015-09
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of Kansas Center for Research, Inc.
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Keywords
Citation
Liu, H., Bennett, C., Matamoros, A., Li, J., Barrett-Gonzalez, R., Rolfe, S., "Improving Infrastructure Sustainability I: Extending Useable Lives of Steel Bridges by Halting Distortion-Induced Fatigue Crack Propagation Using Pretensioned Bolts and Plate Washers," SM Report No. 109, The University of Kansas Center for Research, Inc., Lawrence, KS, September 2015, 67 pp.